New Federal Self-Driving Car Guidelines Threaten Highway Safety

New Federal Self-Driving Car Guidelines Threaten Highway Safety, Consumer Watchdog Warns autonomous vehicle urban mobility

Consumer Watchdog Warns


SANTA MONICA, Calif.Sept. 12, 2017 /PRNewswire-USNewswire/ — The new Federal autonomous vehicle policy released today poses a threat to highway safety, Consumer Watchdog warned and the nonpartisan nonprofit group called for the enactment of enforceable Federal Motor Vehicle Safety Standards specifically covering self-driving cars.


Vision for Safety 2.0

Dubbed a “Vision for Safety 2.0” and released by Secretary of Transportation Elaine Chao, the new policy emphasizes the voluntary nature of the new federal guidelines.

“This isn’t a vision for safety,” said John M. Simpson, Consumer Watchdog’s Privacy Project Director. “It’s a roadmap that allows manufacturers to do whatever they want, wherever and whenever they want, turning our roads into private laboratories for robot cars with no regard for our safety.”

The new Department of Transportation and National Highway Traffic Safety Administration policy focuses only on voluntary guidance for Level 3, Level 4 and Level 5 self-driving cars, not Level 2 technology where only some driving technology is automated, Consumer Watchdog noted.

“This a serious short-coming and ignores the fact that Level 2 technology, like Tesla’s Autopilot, has killed people,” said Simpson. “How the human driver monitors and interacts with Level 2 technologies is potentially life threatening and requires Federal Motor Vehicle Safety Standards.”

The DOT claims the revised voluntary policy “incorporates feedback received through public comments.”

“This simply isn’t true,” Simpson said. “There hasn’t been a NHTSA public hearing on autonomous vehicle policy since President Trump was inaugurated and the highly touted DOT Advisory Committee on Automation in Transportation (ACAT) has not even met and has been completely ignored by Trump’s appointees.”


Voluntary Safety Self-Assessment

The new robot car guidelines raise questions for state regulators, Consumer Watchdog said.  For example, proposed self-driving rules in California mandate that manufacturers would have to file a federal safety assessment with NHTSA.  The new guidance, however, says states should not codify any portion of the voluntary guidance in their regulations.

“Entities are not required to submit a Voluntary Safety Self-Assessment,
nor is there any mechanism to compel entities to do so. While these assessments are encouraged prior to testing and deployment, NHTSA does not require that entities provide disclosures nor are they required to delay testing or deployment. Assessments are not subject to Federal approval.” – Vision for Safety 2.0

View/Download NHTSA vision for safety 2.0 Self driving vehicles

“The DOT and NHTSA ‘Vision for Safety 2.0’ tells auto manufacturers to think about a few things involving robot cars and then do whatever they want,” said Simpson.

Visit website at

SOURCE Consumer Watchdog

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.